5 Essential Steps to a Brand audit, Digital Marketing Audit & When to Rebrand

In a recent DoneMaker podcast I sat down with Chris Fulmer to walk through how you should approach a Brand audit, what to include in a digital marketing audit, and the real signals that mean it’s time to refresh or fully rebrand. If you care about clarity, customer alignment, and marketing that actually moves the needle, this piece breaks the conversation into five practical steps you can start using today.

1. Start your Brand audit with the foundation: identity, position, and promise

When you begin a Brand audit you must treat the brand like a person. Ask yourself: who are you, who do you serve, and what promise do you make? A Brand audit is not just a logo check. It covers the core identity plus market position, target audience, pricing, tone, and the way you communicate internally and externally.

Think about the interview metaphor: if you went into an interview for a job you would prepare your appearance, your experience, and your messaging. Your brand needs to do the same thing. In a Brand audit you map:

• Identity elements: logo, colors, typography, imagery and how they work together.
• Positioning: where you sit vs competitors and what unique value you own.
• Audience definition: who is the ideal customer, and who are you actually attracting?
• Pricing and product fit: does your price communicate the right tier and quality?
• Messaging and tone: does your copy sound like one consistent person or many?

A clear Brand audit reveals if you are cohesive or patchwork. Too many organizations arrive at a Brand audit with years of “quick fixes” and disparate messaging. You might find your website says one thing, your social media says another, and your sales team uses different language in proposals. A Brand audit identifies that fragmentation and sets a north star.

Start at the foundation. If you skip that, everything else is just layer on layer of assumptions.

2. Use the right customer data when you do a Brand audit — design feedback to inform decisions

Collecting customer feedback sounds obvious, but in practice most companies collect the wrong things or collect them inconsistently. When you run a Brand audit you need usable intelligence, not a pile of incomplete surveys. That means designing the right questions up front and being disciplined about the data you accept.

Here are the most useful kinds of questions to include in your Brand audit research:

• What other options did you consider before choosing us? (This reveals alternatives and indirect competitors.)
• Give one reason you almost chose a competitor. (This pinpoints weak moments in the customer journey.)
• If this product didn’t exist, how would you solve the problem? (This uncovers the alternatives and substitution behaviors.)
• How quickly did we respond when you reached out? (Operational feedback that affects perception.)

One concrete concern from the field: a regional construction firm had over five thousand surveys but only about one hundred were usable because questions changed midstream and responses were inconsistent. A Brand audit that wants to rely on user sentiment must ensure survey design and data hygiene from the start.

When you design surveys for a Brand audit, be specific and actionable. Instead of asking “Were you satisfied?” include follow-ups that uncover why, when, and what alternatives customers weighed. The goal is to have feedback that translates into a prioritized action list, not an emotional snapshot.

3. Audit your digital channels — the digital marketing audit is the channels check

If the Brand audit defines who you are, the digital marketing audit shows how you deliver the brand to the world. For many of you this means auditing the channels you use to distribute content and attract customers: website, social, search ads, email, PR, webinars, and even the digital hooks in traditional campaigns.

Key elements to inspect in your digital marketing audit:

• Channel performance: which channels actually bring qualified leads, and which are wasting resources?
• Content quality and indexing: is your content being found and indexed or is it lost in volume?
• Review and reputation management: do reviews match your desired positioning, and are they authentic?
• Backlink health: are you earning real links or buying low-quality backlinks that can trigger penalties?
• Ad efficiency: are your paid channels optimized around clear KPIs and tested creative?

One point to stress: take shortcuts at your own peril. Buying reviews and purchasing spammy backlinks are short-term patches that often lead to long-term declines. Search engines have become far better at rooting out inauthentic behavior and the penalty is real. If your traffic tanks and backlinks explode at the same time, that’s a red flag that your site has been deprioritized for spammy link patterns.

When you approach a digital marketing audit, think of it as an audit of distribution fidelity. How faithfully do your channels represent the foundation found in your Brand audit?

4. Execution after the Brand audit — standardize, prioritize, and iterate

Audits are only useful if you translate outcomes into prioritized actions. After your Brand audit and digital marketing audit you’ll have a set of recommendations. Execution is about turning those recommendations into repeatable processes, not one-off campaigns.

Execution for most brands includes:

• Prioritization: identify the top three initiatives that will move the needle and start there.
• SOPs and standards: build brand playbooks, content guides, and channel SOPs so everyone follows the same rules.
• Measurement: set KPIs and test plans, then measure results consistently and iterate.
• Resourcing: align staff, schedule, and budget to the prioritized plan so implementation doesn’t stall.

Keep the process realistic for your team. A Brand audit should come with a practical rollout plan that fits your capacity. Expect implementation to take longer than you imagine; what looks like a ninety day plan often stretches out. The advantage of breaking work into prioritized chunks is that you create momentum and avoid dropping everything when day-to-day pressure returns.

As you implement, collaborate with your internal teams. You can’t transplant a template into every organization. A Brand audit offers recommendations, but you must adapt the steps to how your company operates. If you include your key customers in the process — especially your highest value customers — you’ll reduce churn and generate buy-in for the new direction.

5. Decide whether to refresh or Rebrand — clear signals from your Brand audit

Many leaders arrive at a Brand audit asking: should we rebrand? The answer depends on the diagnosis. A Brand audit helps you choose the right remedy by identifying the underlying problem.

Three clear reasons a Brand audit will point you toward rebranding:

1. Severe reputation damage that can’t be repaired quickly through transparency and process changes.
2. You’ve reinvented your offering: your current identity no longer reflects the products or customers you serve.
3. Ownership or legal reasons where a new identity is the practical route to move past baggage.

Before you rebrand, ask whether a refresh will close the gap. Many famous successes were refreshes, not wholesale Rebrands. Old Spice didn’t disappear and reinvent from the ground up; they refreshed how they spoke, who they targeted, and how they packaged products. A smart Brand audit will show whether you need a full name, new design language, and repositioning, or whether focused updates and process fixes will do the job.

If you do decide to rebrand, include your most valuable customers in the process. Invite the top portion of your client base to give feedback, preview concepts, and feel ownership. Addition by subtraction is real: some customers who were a fit for the old brand won’t be a fit for the new one — and that can be okay if the new direction serves your strategic goals.

How AI and content volume affect your Brand audit and digital marketing audit

AI has changed how content gets produced, but not its fundamentals. When you do a Brand audit you must evaluate whether the content representing your brand delivers value, not just volume. Google and other platforms are already limiting what they index and push, which means mass-produced, generic content will often be ignored.

Treat AI like an assistant in your Brand audit and content production: use it for first drafts, research, or idea generation, but always verify, edit, and humanize before publishing. A Brand audit should measure content authenticity, factual accuracy, and distinctive point of view — not just frequency.

Also watch for AI pitfalls that affect your reputation: an unverified AI-generated statistic on social can blow up quickly. From a Brand audit perspective, your content must protect your reputation and reflect your values, which requires human oversight.

Practical checklist to run your own Brand audit

Use this checklist as a starting point when you conduct a Brand audit yourself. It is a condensed, actionable list of what to inspect:

• Identity inventory: collect all logo files, visual assets, tone examples, and point-of-sale materials.
• Messaging map: write one-liners for your core promise, value props for each audience segment, and elevator pitch.
• Audience clarity: list your customer segments and the most valuable traits of each.
• Competitive map: identify direct and indirect competitors and any “dangerous” competitors you weren’t aware of.
• Customer feedback plan: design surveys and interviews with specific questions about alternatives, friction points, and responsiveness.
• Digital channel audit: catalog channels, traffic sources, review sentiment, backlink profiles, and indexed pages.
• Implementation plan: prioritize top three initiatives, assign owners, and define KPIs and timelines.

Each item ties directly back to the Brand audit findings. The output of a good Brand audit is not a wall of recommendations — it is a prioritized roadmap your team can implement.

Common pitfalls the Brand audit will reveal (and how to fix them)

When you audit a brand you will almost always run into a handful of recurring problems. Here are the common pitfalls and corrective paths:

• Patchwork messaging: fix with a single messaging framework and require all content to pass a single voice test.
• Incomplete or inconsistent data: redesign surveys and research protocols and collect actionable questions you can track over time.
• Short-term hacks like purchased reviews or backlinks: stop buying shortcuts; instead, create a legitimate review collection process and earn links via real content and partnerships.
• Execution fatigue: build SOPs and set realistic priorities so you don’t start and stop every quarter.

If your Brand audit identifies any of these issues, treat them as process problems rather than purely aesthetic ones. The identity and the operations must align to deliver what the brand promises.

Next steps after your Brand audit:

1. Translate audit findings into a prioritized action plan with owners and timelines.
2. Create or revise SOPs so every piece of content and channel activity maps back to your brand standards.
3. Run experiments against one or two prioritized channels to learn and iterate quickly.
4. Keep a regular cadence of small reviews so the Brand audit becomes a living tool, not a report on a shelf.

Remember: an audit points you where to act. Execution, discipline, and customer focus are what makes an audit transform results.

Where to get help with a Brand audit

If you want professional support, look for partners who pair Brand audit capability with practical implementation experience. You need actionable recommendations and help building a plan that your team can sustain. A good Brand audit partner should ask about goals upfront, design research to those goals, and hand you a prioritized roadmap, not a laundry list.

When you approach a Brand audit you are investing in clarity. You will discover what to stop doing, what to amplify, and what to test. That clarity is the difference between a brand that confuses customers and a brand that attracts and keeps the right ones.

“Start at the foundation. Even when clients think they are further along, we review everything from the ground up.” — Chris Fulmer

If you run a Brand audit and follow the five steps here — foundation, data design, channel audit, disciplined execution, and honest rebrand decisioning — you will leave the noise behind and build a brand that earns attention and trust.

Watch the full podcast here: How to do a brand audit, digital marketing audit & when to rebrand | Chris Fulmer |DoneMaker Podcast

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)